Shelby Oaks (2025) - Quality Production Meet Lazy Script - REVIEW

Source

I got to start by saying that Shely Oak is not as bad as the internet says, I had this one on my bucketlist mainly because of that, low rating reviews, I would suggest bad PR, probably too much hype for what it really is. This movie reminds me a lot of 8MM on how the clues start to unfold like the June 2008 found footage of Riley sitting on a bed looking completely lost, she couldnt stop feeling like shit as she investigates with the Paranormal Paranoids before she vanishes into the dark hallway, I did not expect that turn after everything leading into it, and when the story jumps twelve years ahead to her sister Mia looking for her, the camera drops the raw video style entirely and switches into a normal movie format with real production quality behind it. You get an immediate sense of heavy atmosphere from just brief glimpses of shadows hiding inside those dark second story windows, cutting away early before you can fully process what you are looking at, pairing that visual tension that actually hook you. Camille Sullivan does massive work playing Mia since the whole visual journey is from and through her desperation, showing a woman who refuses to listen to a cynical world telling her to give up on her missing sibling. The camera pans across their empty nursery room stacked with leftover file boxes because she and her husband Robert could not conceive and gave up on their parenting dreams after Riley disappeared and you feel that weight immediately without it been force or oversold by the actors. The transition between that grainy videos uploaded by the ghost hunting crew and the more polished, more like cinematic style of Mia living in Darke County creates an immersive contrast that sets the mood for a dark mystery. You can feel the raw trauma eating her during those talking head interviews with the crew, the way she uses her obsession with the unsolved case as a shield to avoid dealing with her own failing marriage. The sound design stands out during those scenes, steping up every subtle creak and distant sound around her rural property to keep you completely off guard. It is a simple setup that avoids feeling like a cheap scare jumps, focusing instead on the heavy human toll of long term grief while dropping breadcrumbs about something lurking in the background. I love how the movie takes its time establishing the distinct personalities of the doomed YouTube ghost chasers, showing Riley playing acoustic guitar and drawing dark nightmare figures in a sketchbook before everything goes dark. That deliberate pacing makes you actually care about the siblings before the horror starts ramping up, so when things get bad the emotional weight is already there.

• IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt14999684/
• Platform: PRIME VIDEO

[Source](https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/0FDBV1P52WZV035IIWAJFZZ6EM/ref=atv_dp)

There are solid moments during the movie where it finds great strength with impactful moments specially when they are totally unexpected, there is this scene during the documentary where a man named Wilson Miles comes onto the porch looking completely distressed, says that she finally let him go and you are like TF!!, then pulls a gun and blows his brains out right in front of the cameras, leaving blood dripping down the house siding. That scene is caught me off base and then Mia spots a bloody mini cassette labeled Shelby Oaks clutched in his dead hand, quietly snatching the tape from the crime scene without the police noticing so she can uncover the truth herself. She sneaks upstairs to play it on the missing second camera belonging to Riley, the result is her screaming as she watches grainy footage of the ghost hunters searching through a decaying building before running off in panic. The raw terror on that tape works exceptionally well, taking you inside a run down location where a wooden rocking chair creaks on its own before Wilson Miles suddenly bursts through and tears into one of the crew members. What really impressed me is how the entire looks just shifts into the killer point of view, freezing on his face to confirm he is the exact same man who just died outside. Robin Bartlett gives an absolute standout performance as Norma, a stone cold older woman living out in the deep woods, specially looking damn creepy simply by offering Mia questionable meat crackers inside a house completely covered in spreading black mold. Its here stone cold attitude that lift up the creepy atmosphere to another level, perfectly embodying a deranged mother figure who views demonic infection as a literal gift. Michael Beach also brings a welcome dose of authority to the topic playing Detective Burke, adding some more grounded realism as he breaks down the criminal history of Wilson Miles and his strange connection to the abandoned ghost town, you can feel someone is doing the work putting things together so its seperates the character from the horror for a moment. Every scene involving the cassette tapes feels earn rather than been just a simble to generate fear, utilizing vintage cameras and raw audio distortion to transport you directly into the terrifying final moments of the missing crew. I also have to say that the audio and visual choices have enough effect because there is just enough graphic violence to paint the picture as it goes and make you crunch in your seat.

Source

Source

The immersion of the story completely drops off a cliff when characters start making exceptionally dumb decisions just to keep the plot moving, creating these frustrating gaps in logic that you do not fully realize until later, when you think about the movie again. After Wilson Miles shoots himself on the porch, Mia is shown later that evening with blood still across her face, talking to the police and sitting on her living room couch like the bathroom is on another planet. It is the kind of detail that feels minor at first, but once you notice it, the whole scene starts feeling fake, because no normal person would sit around for hours covered in a dead man’s blood while everyone else acts like nothing is wrong. Her husband Robert does not interrupt while she sits in shock and though he eventually checks on her, he mostly acts like a background character who cannot figure out what to do with the situation. You have to seriously question why Mia stubbornly keeps the bloody cassette tape completely hidden from Detective Burke, making the ridiculous excuse that the police will instantly close the missing person investigation just because the killer is dead. It makes zero sense that she refuses to make a digital copy of the murder footage for her own protection before handing the physical evidence over to the authorities. Things start to feel off and the scripts gets even lazier when Mia visits the local library and magically solves the supernatural mystery through a basic internet search for Darke County demonic forces, finding the exact horned figure symbol after twelve years of supposedly exhaustive searching, I guess it was just convinient to the story to take this route to make things easier, this is the type of movie that you just need to leave your brain at the door to enjoy. I was actually got mad when she goes out alone at night to investigate a terrifying abandoned correctional facility, carrying a cheap flickering flashlight instead of bringing backup. She smashes her way inside the dark prison blocks and wanders right into cell 37, completely failing to notice a massive horned monster standing directly over her shoulder while she stares at burn marks on the floor. The movie starts to drag a lot and I guess thats where most people start hating and leaving very low reviews because the pacing plainly sux during this nighttime trips with very little progress to the story and relaying on cheap jump scares involving a snarling green eyed dog, you can tell the script just not helping the story here and also giving Mia very little interaction.

Source

Source

At no point the movie is trying to hide where it got most of its ideas and that part might make it a bit too predictable depending on who is watching the movie, Shelby Oaks is playing with horrors scenes directly from some other cool old supernatural horror, found footage horror, creepy woods horror, all of that stuff and honestly, that part is cool but it also makes the movie feel a little too familiar sometimes, like it is borrowing from a bunch of classics instead of fully becoming its own thing. The beginning is very Blair Witch, with the fake documentary interviews, the missing ghost hunters, the creepy footage, the woods, the weird symbols, and the one tape that shows what happened. Once the movie moves away from that found footage style and becomes a regular movie, it starts feeling more like Rosemary’s Baby mixed with some dirty backwoods captivity horror. Then you get all the Tarion stuff, the Incubus of the North, the hellhounds, Riley being kept hidden for years, and the whole idea that something demonic has been using her body for something horrible. The prison stuff was probably one of the best parts for me, mostly because Keith David shows up as Morton Jacobson and makes all that exposition feel way more serious than it probably should. The movie connects Wilson Miles to cell 37, the Darke County prison riot, the eighteen dead prisoners, and this idea that Wilson basically brought death and rot wherever he went. I liked that because it makes the supernatural mystery feel more like a true crime case where Mia is slowly putting the pieces together, instead of just waiting for the next jump scare or monster scene, but the problem is that if you have seen enough horror movies, you can feel a lot of the turns coming. Shelby Oaks has found footage, occult horror, demonic pregnancy horror, haunted small town mystery, creature stuff, and prison curse stuff all thrown into the same pot, some of it works because the mood is strong and the locations look cold, ugly, and miserable in a good horror way. I think the part that probably throw people off is that they were expecting something ground braking and this isnt it, is more like a solid indie horror movie made by someone who clearly understands the genre, but also loves his influences so much that sometimes they are louder than the movie itself.

After reading most of this post I'm feeling like this was half rant and half I enjoy it enough. Shelby Oaks tries to pull everything together with this messy underground climax, but the final twist honestly makes the whole search feel kind of pointless in a depressing way. Mia finally gets to Norma’s creepy hidden basement and finds Riley alive, but she is completely destroyed by everything that happened to her. Then the movie goes full demonic ritual, with Norma doing her blood sacrifice thing over the baby and Tarion basically becoming the real force behind everything, and at first you think, okay, Mia finally found her sister, maybe there is still some tiny piece of hope here. But nope, the movie immediately rips that away too. Riley gets brought back, tries to smother the baby because she knows that thing is not normal, and Mia stops her like she is saving an innocent child, even though the movie has basically been screaming that this baby is bad news. Then they struggle, Mia accidentally sends Riley out the upstairs window, and just when you think that is already horrible enough, the hellhounds come in and finish her off in the yard. It is a brutal ending, but also kind of frustrating, because Riley survives twelve years of pure nightmare just to die like that five minutes after being found. The final idea is strong, though. Tarion showing up behind Mia and the movie revealing that he was watching both sisters the whole time is creepy as hell. Riley was the one used to have the child, but Mia was the one he really wanted to raise it. I like that as a dark horror ending, and Camille Sullivan really sells that final scream like her whole soul just got crushed, but I can say thats enought because it makes the investigation feel weirdly hollow since Mia was never really solving anything. She was basically being dragged to trap the entire time without knowing much so instead of giving the sisters any real emotional resolution, the movie goes for one last nasty twist that fleat like a cheat code. I respect it but I also get why it can feel like the script is punishing the audience more than giving us a satisfying ending. Even with the messy logic and some annoying character choices, I came out glad I watched it. Shelby Oaks has real atmosphere, nasty locations, a strong found footage opening and enough creepy indie horror energy to make it worth it so I would still give it around a 7.5 out of 10.

#shelbyoaks, #chrisstuckman, #horrorreview, #foundfootage, #mockumentary, #supernatural, #indiehorror, #camillesullivan, #sarahdurn, #michaelbeach, #keithdavid, #robinbartlett, #demonicpossession, #incubus, #hellhounds, #paranormalparanoids, #ohioghosttown, #spookyseason, #creaturefeature, #atmospherictension, #filmmakingdebut, #horrortropes, #mysterythriller, #movierecommendation, #spoilercritique

Posted Using INLEO